Debate rages in India on IVF for women over 50

In this Dec. 22, 2016 photo, framed newspaper clippings on patients are hung on a wall inside the National Fertility and Test Tube Baby Centre in Hisar, India. The packed waiting room at Dr. Anurag Bishnoi’s clinic bears witness to the fact that working-class families across the country are willing to spend their limited savings for a child of their own. The cost of IVF treatment in India is relatively low, even though many families have to pay on their own. At Bishnoi's clinic, one cycle of IVF costs about 110,000 rupees ($1,700), compared to about $12,000 in the U.S. (AP Photo/Altaf Qadri)
In this Dec. 22, 2016 photo, a pathologist works in a laboratory inside the National Fertility and Test Tube Baby Centre in Hisar, India. Most medical ethics guidelines around the world recommend a cut-off between 45 and 50 for treatments like IVF, and the Indian Medical Council sets 45 as the recommended age limit. Across the United States and most parts of western Europe, insurance companies usually stop paying for IVF treatment after 45. In the United Kingdom, the limit for fertility treatments under the National Health Service is 42. (AP Photo/Altaf Qadri)
In this Dec. 23, 2016 photo, Gurdev Singh, right, laughs as he sits on a cot next to his elder brothers Puran Singh, second right, and Hazur Singh holding his niece Gurjeet, left, in the compound of their house in Ellenabad, India. Gurjeet is the child Gurdev Singh's wife Manjeet Kaur yearned for desperately, after 40 years of being that thing which a rural Indian woman dreads more than almost anything else - barren. She gave birth at 58 years old, with help from a controversial IVF clinic in this corner of north India that specializes in fertility treatments for women over 50. (AP Photo/Altaf Qadri)
ADDS FIRST NAME OF DR. BISHNOI - In this Dec. 22, 2016 photo, photographs of Hindu deities are placed on a poster of a doctor holding a baby inside the National Fertility and Test Tube Baby Centre in Hisar, India. The packed waiting room at Dr. Anurag Bishnoi’s clinic bears witness to the fact that working-class families across the country are willing to spend their limited savings for a child of their own. The cost of IVF treatment in India is relatively low, even though many families have to pay on their own. At Bishnoi's clinic, one cycle of IVF costs about 110,000 rupees ($1,700), compared to about $12,000 in the U.S. (AP Photo/Altaf Qadri)
In this Dec. 22, 2016 photo, Dr. Anurag Bishnoi, bottom, browses through photographs of his patients on his iPad in his office at the National Fertility and Test Tube Baby Centre in Hisar, India. The packed waiting room at Bishnoi’s clinic bears witness to the fact that working-class families across the country are willing to spend their limited savings for a child of their own. The cost of IVF treatment in India is relatively low, even though many families have to pay on their own. At Bishnoi's clinic, one cycle of IVF costs about 110,000 rupees ($1,700), compared to about $12,000 in the U.S. (AP Photo/Altaf Qadri)
In this Dec. 23, 2016 photo, Manjeet Kaur, left, watches her daughter Gurjeet crawling in the compound of their house in Ellenabad, India. Gurjeet is the child Kaur yearned for desperately, after 40 years of being that thing which a rural Indian woman dreads more than almost anything else - barren. She gave birth at 58 years old, with help from a controversial IVF clinic in this corner of north India that specializes in fertility treatments for women over 50. (AP Photo/Altaf Qadri)
ADDS FIRST NAME OF DR. BISHNOI - In this Dec. 22, 2016 photo, Indian patients, seen from behind a fogged glass, wait for consultation inside the National Fertility and Test Tube Baby Centre in Hisar, India. The packed waiting room at Dr. Anurag Bishnoi’s clinic bears witness to the fact that working-class families across the country are willing to spend their limited savings for a child of their own. The cost of IVF treatment in India is relatively low, even though many families have to pay on their own. At Bishnoi's clinic, one cycle of IVF costs about 110,000 rupees ($1,700), compared to about $12,000 in the U.S. (AP Photo/Altaf Qadri)
In this Dec. 23, 2016 photo, Manjeet Kaur, left, and her husband Gurdev Singh, right, walk with their daughter Gurjeet Kaur in the compound of their house in Ellenabad, India. Gurjeet is the child Kaur yearned for desperately, after 40 years of being that thing which a rural Indian woman dreads more than almost anything else - barren. She gave birth at 58 years old, with help from a controversial IVF clinic in this corner of north India that specializes in fertility treatments for women over 50. (AP Photo/Altaf Qadri)

ELLENABAD, India — To see Manjeet Kaur around her little daughter is to see joy at its purest.

The 15-month-old toddles about the sprawling courtyard of her parents' farm, her oily curls tied up in a top knot, her rubber-soled shoes squeaking. Kaur's eyes don't miss a thing, and they often mist up with tears.

Gurjeet is the child Kaur yearned for desperately, after 40 years of being that thing which a rural Indian woman dreads more than almost anything else — barren. She gave birth at 58 years old, with help from a controversial IVF clinic in this corner of north India that specializes in fertility treatments for women over 50.

Such treatments have become more common across the world, and they strike a cultural chord in India, where a woman is often defined by her ability to be a wife and mother. While there are no reliable statistics for how many Indian women undergo fertility treatments each year at what age, tens of thousands of IVF clinics have sprouted up in the country over the last decade.

Fertility specialists say pregnancies like Kaur's are troubling because of the potential health risks and the concern that the parents may not live long enough to raise their babies to adulthood. Legislation is pending in India's Parliament setting 50 as the legal upper age cap.

But Dr. Anurag Bishnoi, the driving force behind the National Fertility and Test Tube Baby Centre in Hisar, harbors no such worries. His clinic's website home page is dominated by photographs of patients who carried babies to term at ages well beyond what most other doctors anywhere in the world may permit. At least two of his patients gave birth at 70.

For Kaur, it's simple enough. Bishnoi made her belong.

"You have no idea how I suffered," she says of her life before her daughter.

Kaur married her husband, Gurdev Singh, when she was 18 and he was just a little older than 20. She simply assumed that children would follow marriage. But no children came.

She felt worthless.

"I asked God why he had abandoned me," she says, as she nervously fidgets with the green scarf she uses to cover her almost entirely grey hair.

With each decade she felt the dream slip further away. The couple tried IVF twice in their 40s. It didn't work.

A woman in Kaur's setting, without a child, is an inauspicious creature. Her very presence is shunned at social gatherings, especially at weddings and birth ceremonies which celebrate fecundity.

They lived, like most rural Indians, with extended family, and Kaur showered all her love on the nephew and niece she helped raise. It was Kaur's nephew who first heard of Bishnoi, the doctor in the nearby town of Hisar, who had built a prosperous medical practice and tidy little business empire by helping aging women across north India have children through in-vitro fertilization.

"Doctor sahib was like a god to us," Singh says.

Dr. Anurag Bishnoi is called many things. God and quack top the list.

His critics accuse the embryologist of making money off the dreams of the desperate, and of taking wildly unnecessary risks. When Bishnoi helped a 70-year-old woman to give birth last April, Dr. Hrishikesh Pai, who heads a federation of Indian gynecologists and obstetricians, called him a "rogue doctor" who ignores the self-imposed guidelines that most fertility specialists follow.

Dr. Narendra Malhotra, who heads the Indian Society For Assisted Reproduction, says Bishnoi has been attempting to "play God."

"We don't endorse making mothers out of grandmothers," he says. "It's too risky for the women. Their bodies are not designed to bear children after 50."

He says his association has requested that Bishnoi stop working with significantly older women, with no success.

"He's not breaking any law because there is no law," Malhotra says.

Most medical ethics guidelines around the world recommend a cut-off between 45 and 50 for treatments like IVF, and the Indian Medical Council sets 45 as the recommended age limit. Across the United States and most parts of western Europe, insurance companies usually stop paying for IVF treatment after 45.

Every now and then, news reports pop up about women across the world giving birth in their 50s and 60s but most doctors offering assisted reproductive treatments to women over 50 do it on the down low. But Bishnoi doesn't hesitate to promote his work.

Bishnoi says he chooses his patients after a series of medical examinations and has never had a patient die.

For older patients like Kaur, who make up 20 percent of his practice, Bishnoi harvests eggs from anonymous donors, but in a deeply patriarchal culture, what really matters is that the sperm belongs to the father. He likens his patients to the military.

"They are soldiers of their family," he says. "And of course the risks involved are there, but soldiers don't care."

The packed waiting room at Bishnoi's clinic bears witness to the fact that working-class families across the country are willing to spend their limited savings for a child of their own. The cost of IVF treatment in India is relatively low, even though many families have to pay on their own. At Bishnoi's clinic, one cycle of IVF costs about 110,000 rupees ($1,700), compared to about $12,000 in the U.S.

Gurdev Singh says the money was nothing. "What matters is that he gave us our little doll."

Kaur and Singh say they feel no fear and anxiety about raising their child at an age when most people are grandparents.

"This is all God's will," Singh says.

Kaur says she has no trouble at all taking care of her daughter. In fact, she is already thinking of trying IVF again to give Gurjeet a sibling. She waits, impatiently, for the day when she can talk to her child.

"One day when she is older, she will share my joys and sorrows," Kaur says. "She will ask me, 'Mummy, how did you pass the days before I came?'"

___

Follow Muneeza Naqvi on Twitter at twitter.com/mnaqvi10

___

A longer version of this story can be found here: https://apnews.com/b3180ed72511491188f9be0b77122f39/Controversial-IVF-doctor-gives-hope-to-older-Indian-women

Must Read

India plans surrogacy ban for foreigners,...

Aug 24, 2016

The Indian government plans to ban foreigners, single parents and gay couples from using India's...

Indian police detain 6 for New Year's Eve...

Jan 4, 2017

Police have detained at least six suspects days after outrage erupted in India over several women...

Library grounds in southern India turn into quiet...

Feb 18, 2017

In the congested southern Indian city of Hyderabad, the sprawling grounds of the central library...

Girl found living with monkeys in Indian forest

Apr 6, 2017

Indian police are reviewing reports of missing children to try to identify a girl who was found...

Police patrol for poachers as animals flee...

Jul 10, 2017

Police are patrolling for poachers as rhinoceros, deer and buffalo move to higher ground to escape...

About Us

Daily Tech Geek delivers Technology news only covering the multiple fields in the industry.

Contact us: sales[at]dailytechgeek.com

Subscribe Now!