US exporting dirty fuel to already pollution-choked India

In this July 14, 2017 photo, villagers work in rice fields in Moradabad 178 kilometers (110 miles) from New Delhi. The villagers complained of ailments, which they blame on pollution from local factories, some of which are fueled by petroleum coke. They see the skies getting dingier but have little information about what happens behind factory gates. India’s energy-hungry industries like petcoke because it’s cheaper and burns hotter than coal; they also defend their use by saying they’re recycling a waste that’s being produced anyway. India’s Supreme Court recently banned petcoke use by some industries as of Nov. 1 in the three states surrounding pollution-choked New Delhi. (AP Photo/Vaishnavee Sharma)
In this July 14, 2017 photo, domestically produced petroleum coke is loaded onto a truck to be transported to factories, at a railway station in Rampur, about 210 kilometers (130 miles) from New Delhi, India. Petcoke is the black, bottom-of-the-barrel oil-refining waste that containing more sulfur than what's allowed in coal. Within a decade, India’s petcoke appetite grew so voracious that it began producing and selling its own, and Indian refineries today are making about as much as the country is importing. (AP Photo/Vaishnavee Sharma)
In this July 6, 2017 photo, domestically produced petroleum coke rests in an open air depot in Moradabad about 178 kilometers (110 miles) from New Delhi, India. Petcoke, the bottom-of-the-barrel waste from refining Canadian tar sands crude and other heavy oils, is cheaper and burns hotter than coal. But it also contains more planet-warming carbon and far more heart- and lung-damaging sulfur. Critics say it is making a bad situation worse across India. About 1.1 million Indians die prematurely as a result of outdoor air pollution every year, according to the Health Effects Institute, a nonprofit funded by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency and industry. Within a decade, India’s petcoke appetite grew so voracious that it began producing and selling its own, and Indian refineries today are making about as much as the country is importing. (AP Photo/Vaishnavee Sharma)
In this Sept. 21, 2017 photo, petroleum coke, the grainy black byproduct of refining Canadian tar sands oil, is visible at the BP Whiting refinery in East Chicago, Ind. The U.S. is the world's largest producer and exporter of "petcoke," with the largest share being shipped to India in recent years. The high-carbon, high-sulfur fuel is dirtier than coal, and has been burned unregulated in Indian factories and power plants, contributing to that nation's already-high air pollution levels. (DroneBase via AP)
In this Oct. 23, 2017 photo, a doctor examines Jagat Singh, 59, at the Delhi Heart and Lung Institute in New Delhi, India. Over the past decade, pollution has sharply increased in New Delhi with more cars, a construction boom and small factories on the outskirts that burn dirty fossil fuels with little oversight. In October and November, for the second year in a row, city air pollution levels were so high they couldn’t be measured, and newspapers ran headlines warning of an “Airpocalypse.” About 1.1 million Indians die prematurely as a result of outdoor pollution every year. (AP Photo/Tsering Topgyal)
In this July 14, 2017 photo, contractual laborers who sweep and collect petroleum coke for transport to factories display their hands in Rampur, about about 210 kilometers (130 miles) from New Delhi, India. Petroleum coke, the bottom-of-the-barrel leftover from refining Canadian tar sands crude and other heavy oils, is cheaper and burns hotter than coal. But it also contains more planet-warming carbon and far more heart- and lung-damaging sulfur - a key reason few American companies use it. Refineries instead are sending it around the world, especially to energy-hungry India, which last year got almost a fourth of all the fuel-grade “petcoke” the U.S. shipped out, an Associated Press investigation found. (AP Photo/Vaishnavee Sharma)
In this July 14, 2017 photo, a worker places the cover back on the underground furnace used for making bricks after depositing a petroleum coke and coal mixture in it for fuel in Moradabad, about 178 kilometers (110 miles) away from New Delhi. Petcoke, critics say, is making a bad situation worse across India. About 1.1 million Indians die prematurely as a result of outdoor air pollution every year, according to the Health Effects Institute, a nonprofit funded by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency and industry. India’s energy-hungry industries like petcoke because it’s cheaper and burns hotter than coal; they also defend their use by saying they’re recycling a waste that’s being produced anyway. (AP Photo/Vaishnavee Sharma)
In this July 14, 2017 photo, Baburam sweeps domestically produced petroleum coke to be transported onto trucks hired by local factories in Rampur about 210 kilometers (130 miles) from New Delhi, India. The petcoke being burned in countless factories and plants is contributing to dangerously filthy air in India, which already has many of the world’s most polluted cities. India’s energy-hungry industries like petcoke because it’s cheaper and burns hotter than coal; they also defend their use by saying they’re recycling a waste that’s being produced anyway. (AP Photo/Vaishnavee Sharma)
In this Sept. 21, 2017 photo, petroleum coke, the grainy black byproduct of refining Canadian tar sands oil, is visible at the BP Whiting refinery in East Chicago, Ind. The U.S. is the world's largest producer and exporter of "petcoke," with the largest share being shipped to India in recent years. The high-carbon, high-sulfur fuel is dirtier than coal, and has been burned unregulated in Indian factories and power plants, contributing to that nation's already-high air pollution levels. (DroneBase via AP)

NEW DELHI — U.S. oil refineries that are unable to sell a dirty fuel waste product at home are exporting vast quantities of it to India instead.

Petroleum coke, the leftover from refining Canadian tar sands and other heavy crude, is cheaper and burns hotter than coal. But it also contains more planet-warming carbon and far more heart- and lung-damaging sulfur — a key reason few American companies use it.

Refineries are sending it around the world instead, especially to energy-hungry India, which last year got almost a fourth of the fuel grade "petcoke" the U.S. ships, an Associated Press investigation found. In 2016, the U.S. sent more than 8 million metric tons of petcoke to India — about 20 times more than in 2010, and enough to fill the Empire State Building eight times.

The petcoke burned in countless factories and plants is contributing to dangerously filthy air in India.

Resident Satye Bir doesn't know why Delhi's air is so dirty, but feels fury and resignation.

"My life is finished....My lungs are finished," said Bir, 63, wheezing and reaching for an inhaler. "This is how I survive. Otherwise, I can't breathe."

Tests on imported petcoke used near the capital found 17 times more sulfur than the limit for coal, according to India's Environmental Pollution Control Authority. India's own petcoke, produced domestically, adds to the pollution.

Industry officials say petcoke has been an important fuel for decades, and its use recycles a waste product.

Health and environmental advocates say the U.S. is exporting an environmental problem. The U.S. is the biggest producer and exporter of petcoke in the world.

"We should not become the dust bin of the rest of the world," said Sunita Narain, a pollution authority member who heads the Center for Science and the Environment. "We're choking to death already."

Oil refining is a lifeline in America's industrial heartland. In northwest Indiana, a refinery and steel mills dominate the Lake Michigan shoreline, and smokestacks still symbolize opportunity.

Workers cheered when the BP Whiting refinery invested $4.2 billion to process crude extracted from Canada's tar sands.

Dozens of U.S. refineries built units called cokers to process heavy crude into petroleum products, but huge amounts of petcoke remained.

The American Fuel and Petrochemical Manufacturers told the AP that cokers "allow the United States to export petroleum coke to more than 30 countries to meet growing market demand."

But experts say it's not market forces that are driving U.S. refiners to sell this waste product. They say refineries just need to get rid of it, and are willing to discount it steeply.

"It's like the Wild West," said oil analyst Stuart Ehrenreich, who once managed Koch Industries petcoke export terminals.

Petcoke is sold around the world. Among the largest traders are Oxbow Energy Solutions and Koch Carbon, led by members of the politically conservative Koch family.

Neither they nor a dozen U.S. oil companies and traders contacted by the AP would talk about petcoke. They cited past controversies over waste storage at Midwest refineries or wanted to avoid angering business partners.

In India, no factory managers would allow AP access, and the country's federal officials did not respond to interview requests.

Petcoke, critics say, is making a bad situation worse across India.

About 1.1 million Indians die prematurely as a result of outdoor air pollution every year, according to the nonprofit Health Effects Institute.

"Fifty percent of children in Delhi have abnormalities in their lung function — asthma, bronchitis, a recurring spasmodic cough. That's 2.2 million children," said Dr. Sai Kiran Chaudhuri, the Delhi Heart & Lung Institute's pulmonary chief.

It's impossible to gauge how much pollution is from petcoke versus other sources. But experts say it is contributing to the problem. Last year, 65 percent of India's petcoke came from the U.S., according to trade data provider Export Genius.

In Moradabad, dozens of factories buy petcoke from middlemen, according to Sarvesh Bansal, who leads the local environmental group WatAir.

"We want the factories moved very far away from here," said rice farmer Mohammad Sarfaraz, 25, who lives in nearby Farid Nagar. He and others don't know what pollutants are being spewed, but they protested at factories a few years ago. "Many illnesses occur because of the factories."

India's petcoke appetite prompted it to begin producing its own. Still, U.S. petcoke remains popular.

J.P. Gupta, whose Moradabad factory makes acrylic fibers for clothing, said he burns Indian petcoke. The factory spent about $300,000 to control sulfur, he said, but would have spent 50 percent more on pollution controls for U.S. petcoke, which he says is dirtier.

"There are some who are not bothering about the pollution," he said.

At an open-air brick kiln down the road, workers shoveled petcoke and coal into a furnace. Such small factories account for at least a quarter of India's energy generation.

But few adhere to pollution standards, said Ajay Mathur, head of The Energy Research Institute.

The Indian environment ministry has denied petcoke threatens New Delhi's public health. However, National Green Tribunal judges demanded in May that the government investigate petcoke's health impacts. And the Supreme Court later banned petcoke use by some industries in states surrounding the capital and demanded pollution standards that could further limit use nationwide.

The ministry refused interview requests.

If pollution limits affect India petcoke use, U.S. refiners will find new customers, perhaps in Asia and Africa, experts and environmentalists said.

"It's a classic case of environmental dumping," said Lorne Stockman, director of the environmental group Oil Change International. "They need to get rid of it, so it's dumped into a poor, developing country."

___

Webber reported from Chicago.

___

Follow Tammy Webber and Katy Daigle at www.twitter.com/twebber02 and www.twitter.com/katydaigle

Must Read

Doctors in India remove 40 knives from man's...

Aug 23, 2016

Doctors in northern India say they've surgically removed 40 knives from the stomach of a man who...

Indian court acquits actor Salman Khan of using...

Jan 18, 2017

An Indian court has acquitted top Bollywood star Salman Khan on a charge of using unlicensed...

Elephant habitats shrink in India as...

Feb 10, 2017

Wildlife activists say human encroachment in the forests of northeast India has forced elephants...

Debate rages in India on IVF for women over 50

May 25, 2017

Scores of women in India give birth at advanced ages with the help of a controversial doctor who...

A wealthier India sees alarming rise in...

Jun 2, 2017

A two-decade economic boom has led to obesity in India's youth, and diabetes cases are rising among...

About Us

Daily Tech Geek delivers Technology news only covering the multiple fields in the industry.

Contact us: sales[at]dailytechgeek.com

Subscribe Now!